Who are they trying to kid?
With the evenings getting colder and darker, I’ve been spending more time in front of the TV and I’ve discovered something: TV advertisers think we’re stupid.
What do I mean?
Here are 3 things I’ve seen in TV ads in the last few days:
(1) Alan Hansen pushing a shopping trolley around Morrisons because it saves him money.
(2) The queen of detox diets, Carol Vorderman, marvelling at saving a few pence on some crappy pizzas at Iceland.
(3) Joan Collins queuing to get served at a post office.
(the only true-to-life thing about the Post Office ad was the staff chatting among each other while a customer was waiting)
None of these things has credibility. So, why are they being used to sell? And, do they work?
My answers to these questions:
(a) I don’t know.
(b) I don’t know.
There are three reasons why the ads might work:
Firstly, each of the 3 ads contains a sales message (two of them are price and the Post Office ad lists services available from the P.O.) and getting your sales message from the mouth of a celeb - even when that celeb is incongruous with the product/message - is usually better than not getting it out at all.
Secondly, all three sales messages are fairly “factual”. They don’t really need you to take a leap of faith and trust them.
Thirdly, the “what the f*** is Alan Hansen doing in a supermarket” effect draws people’s attention to the ads.
Those are the reasons why they might work, but on the flipside, the endorsements are so phoney they’re robbed of any power.
My guess is that all three ads could have been improved by showing an “ordinary looking person” talking about their experience.
Steve